The basic rules to be followed and various requirements to be satisfied for masonry construction are specified in the codes of practice for structural masonry construction. This particular document is based on the European structural design codes - EC6 and EC8. Eurocode 6 specifies the rules and provisions for structural masonry. Additional provisions to be considered for masonry construction in earthquake prone areas are outlined in Eurocode 8. In this portion of the website is discussed improved form of brick masonry, namely confined masonry. In this system the masonry walls are confined with reinforced members, however the walls themselves carry all of the gravity and lateral loads. With the increased popularity and availability of reinforced concrete and reinforced block masonry, this type of construction has become common for low-rise houses in many areas of Latin America, Indian Subcontinent and Asia as well as in some parts of Europe.

Although an improved masonry system, it is vulnerable to earthquakes when not well conceived. The following main points should be covered for an earthquake resistant construction :
Materials for confined masonry construction
Masonry units
EC6 provides specifications regarding the use of the following masonry units:
  • Fired clay units
  • Fired clay lightweight units
  • Calcium silicate units
  • Concrete block units
  • Lightweight concrete block units
  • Autoclaved aerated concrete units
The properties of masonry units should comply with the requirements of relevant European standards (EN 771-1-6). Masonry units are classified into the following types: solid, perforated unit, hollow unit, cellular unit, horizontally perforated unit- see Figure 1.
Types of masonry units
Figure 1- Types of masonry units (7)
Solid masonry units are either units without recesses or units with recesses that are filled with mortar during construction, or units with up to 25% by volume of vertical holes. Considering the total volume of holes, volume of any hole, area of any hole, as well as combined thickness of webs and shells, EC6 provides the following classification (Table 1):
Criteria 1 2a 2b 3
Volume of holes
(% of the gross
volume)1
<=25 >25-45 for
clay units,
>25-50 for concrete
aggregate units
>45-55 for
clay units,
>50-60 for concrete
aggregate units2
<=70
Volume of any
hole(% of the
gross volume)
<=12.5 <=12.5 for
clay units,
<=25 for concrete
aggregate units
<=12.5 for
clay units,
<=25 for concrete
aggregate units2
Limited by
(see below)
Area
of any hole
Limited by
volume
(see above)
Limited by
volume
(see above)
Limited by
volume
(see above)
<=2800mm2
except units
with a single
hole when the
hole should be
<=18000mm2
Combined thickness
(% of the overall width)3
>=37.5 >=30 >=20 No requirement
Notes:
1. Holes may consist of formed vertical holes through the unit or frogs or recesses.
2. If there is national experience, based on tests, that confirms that the safety of the masonry is not reduced unacceptably when a higher proportion of holes is incorporated, the limit of 55% for clay units and 60% for concrete aggregate units may be increased for masonry units that are used in the country with national experience.
3.The combined thickness is the thickness of webs and shells, measured horizontally across the unit at right angles to the face of the wall
Table 1- EC 6 requirements for the grouping of masonry units
This classification is employed to select the corection factor K in cases where the characteristic compressive strength fk and shear strength fvk of the masonry are calculated on the basis of empirical formulae correlating normalised compressive strength of masonry units fb and mortar fm.
EC 8 provides further requirements for hollow units used for earthquake resistant masonry construction as listed:
  • The units have less than 50% holes(in % of gross volume)
  • Minimum thickness of shells is 15mm
  • The vertical webs in hollow and cellular units extend over the entire horizontal length of the unit
In the relevant European standards (EN 771-1-6) are given minimum mean values of compressive strength of masonry units to be used for masonry walls:
  • Clay units: min fb=2.5 MPa
  • Calcium silicate units: min fb=5.0 MPa
  • Concrete units: min fb=1.8 MPa
  • Autoclaved aerated concrete units: min fb=1.8 MPa
  • Manufactured stone units: min fb=15 MPa
According to the EC 8, the minimum normalised compressive strength of masonry unit, normal to the bed face, is fb=2.5 MPa. In the case of hollow clay units and concrete block units it is recommended that the minimum compressive strength is 7.5 MPa, especially for reinforced masonry walls construction. EC 6 suggests the use of normalised compressive strength fb for design. This is the mean value determined by testing of at least ten equivalent, air dried, 100 mm by 100 mm specimens cut from the masonry unit.
In the case where the strength is obtained by testing full sized units, the mean value of strength is multiplied by the shape factor d, which takes into account the actual dimensions of the unit. In case the compressive stength of masonry is specified as characteristic strength, it should be first converted to the mean equivalent using a conversion factor based on the coefficient of variation, and than multiplied by the shape factor d (Table 2).
Shape factor d for conversion of mean value of unit's strength to normalised value (EC6)
Height [mm] Least horizontal dimension [mm]
50 100 150 200 >250
50 0.85 0.75 0.70 - -
65 0.95 0.85 0.75 0.70 0.65
100 1.15 1.00 0.90 0.80 0.75
150 1.30 1.20 1.10 1.00 0.95
200 1.45 1.35 1.25 1.15 1.10
>250 1.55 1.45 1.35 1.25 1.15
Table 2- Shape factor for conversion of mean value of unit's strength to normalised value (4)
Mortar
According to the specification used in EC 6, several types of mortar can be used for masonry walls:
  • General purpose mortar, used in joints with thickness greater than 3mm and produced with dense aggregate
  • Thin layer mortar, which is designed for use in masonry with nominal thickness of joints 1-3mm
  • Lightweight mortar, which is made using perlite, expanded clay, expanded shale etc. Lightweight mortars typically have a dry hardened density lower than 1500kg/m3.
In the Table 3 below are shown typical composition of prescribed general purpose mortar mixes and expected mean compressive strength.
Mortar type Mean
compresive
strength
Approximate composition in parts of volume
Cement Hydrated lime Sand
M2 2.5 MPa 1 1.25-2.50 2.25-3 times
cement and lime
M5 5 MPa 1 0.50-1.25
M10 10 MPa 1 0.25-0.50
M20 20 MPa 1 0-0.25
Table 3- Typical prescribed composition and strength of general purpose mortars (39)
Mortars to be used in masonry construction in earthquake regions should comply with EC 8. According to this standard for the construction of plain and confined masonry, the minimum compressive strength of mortar fm is set to 5 MPa. Confined masonry walls can be reinforced with bed joint reinforcement, which is anchored in the tie-columns. In such cases mortar with minimum compressive strength of 10 MPa is required, since the rebars are embedded in mortar. The bond strength is specified as a function of type of rebar and type of mortar. The recommended values of characteristic bond strength fbok are specified in the Table 4 below:
Mortar M5-M9 M10-M14 M15-M19 M20
fbok for plain
bars [MPa]
0.7 1.2 1.4 1.5
fbok for high-
bond bars [MPa]
1 1.5 2.0 2.5
Table 4- Characteristic anchorage bond strength of reinforcement in mortar (4)
Mechanical properties of mortar are determined by testing mortar prisms 40x40x160mm (EN1015-11). The compressive strength of the mortar is calculated after averaging the strength values of six specimens. The thickness of bed and head joints is recommended to be in the range 8-15mm and all head joints should be fully filled with mortar.
Reinforcing steel
Steel bars are used as reinforcement in the case of reinforced masonry and confined masonry. According to EC 6, reinforcing steel may be assumed to possess adequate elongation ductility, if the following requirements are satisfied:
  • for high dutility class: euk > 5% and (ft/fy)k > 1.08
  • for normal dutility class: euk > 2.5% and (ft/fy)k > 1.05,
where:
e uk= the characteristic value of the unit elongation at max tensile stress,
ft= tensile strength of rebar steel,
fy= yield strength of rebar steel,
(ft/fy)k = the characteristic value of ft/fy
In the case where high bond rebars with diameter less than 6mm is used it should not be considered as having high ductility. When prefabricated ladder-type or truss-type bed joint reinforcement is used it should be considered as having normal ducility. Typical anchorages of reinforcing bars are shown on Figure 2.
Typical anchorages of reinforcing bars
Figure 2- Typical anchorages of reinforcing bars (4)
Definition of confined masonry construction system
To beginning of document
A constructioin system where a plain masonry walls are confined on all four sides by RC members or reinforced masonry is called confined masonry. The major imrovements in the performance of the confined masonry building over the plain masonry building are as follows:
  • Enhances greatly the connection between structural walls
  • Improves the stability of masonry walls
  • Improves the strength of masonry walls
  • Provides ductility under earthquake loading
  • Improves the integrity and containment of earthquake damaged masonry walls
The RC confining elements are horizontal members called bond-beams and vertical members called tie-columns (Figure 3).
In the case of confined masonry floors should be reinforced concrete cast in-situ. Good floor to wall connection is achieved by horizontal bond beams cast just below slabs.
Confined masonry
Figure 3- Solid units masonry confined with tie-columns and bond beams
RC confining elements are mostly used for solid masonry units construction. When masonry units from group 2a or 2b are used the horizontal and vertical confining elements are formed by reinforced concrete block masonry units which are subsequently grouted. For appropriate details for these refer the Confined block masonry section of this website.

The confining elements are not intended nor designed to perform as a moment-resisting frames. When such frames are constructed to resist lateral and vertical loads the purpose of the masonry walls is only for space partitioning, and the construction system is called masonry-infilled frames. In the masonry-infilled frames type of housing the reinforced concrete frame structure is constructed first. The masonry is constructed later between the RC members. In the case of confined masonry, the masonry walls are load-bearing and are constructed to carry all of the gravity loads as well as lateral loads.

Therefore the load-bearing masonry walls are constructed first. Then the vertical and horizontal confining elements are cast simultaneously with the floors, which are constructed as RC slab.
In order to achieve effective confinement of walls, vertical confining elements( tie-columns) should be located at all corners and changes of wall contour, and at all joints, wall intersections and free ends of structural walls. Vertical confining members are also necessary at both sides of any opening which according to EC 8 has an area more than 1.5 m2. According to [TOMASEVIC REFERENCE] this requirement can be relaxed for openings area up to 2.5 m2. The distance between tie-columns should not exceed 4.0 m. Figure 4, below shows typical distribution of vertical confining elements in the plan of the building.
Vertical confining elements distribution
Figure 4- Typical distribution of vertical confining elements in the plan of a building
Normally the tie-columns fit into the thickness of masonry wall and the minimum tie-column cross section is 150x150 mm. The concrete for the confining members should be min grade C15. According to EC 6, the contribution of the tie-columns and bond-beams to the lateral resistance of the masonry house should not be taken into account. Consequently specific design calculations for confining elements are not required. The amount of reinforcement in vertical and horizontal confining elements is determined on empirical basis.

The min steel tie-columns reinforcement for construction in seismic zones is specified in EC 8. According to this code the min reinforcement area for tie-columns is 240 mm2. For tie-columns at the house corners and wall intersections, it is recommended that, at least 4 f10 mild steel bars are used for reinforcement. In this case the total steel area is 314 mm2. Mild steel stirrups f10 are placed uniformly distributed at 200 mm offsets.

Although the tie-columns and bond beams do not provide frame system adequate splicing and anchoring of rebars is required at all joints. Sixty rebar diameters splices are required according to EC 8.

In some resources[10] is provided tabulated data where the area or rebars can be selected in dependence of seismicity of the location and nuber of storeys in the house. Such data is presented below in Table 5 for tie-columns.
No of
storeys
Low:
ag < 0.1g
Moderate:
0.1g < ag < 0.2g
High:
0.2g < ag < 0.4g
2 1-2 4f8 4f10 4f12
4 1-2 4f8 4f10 4f12
4 2-4 4f8 4f10 4f12
6 1-2 4f10 4f12 4f14
6 3-4 4f8 4f10 4f12
6 5-6 4f8 4f10 4f12
Table 5- Recommended reinforcement for vertical confining elements (9)
To enforce the confinement of plane masonry by the confining members EC 8 requires connecting the masonry and tie-columns by means of rebar diameter f6 min at max 600 mm appart. These links should be anchored at least 250 mm into the mortar joints.
Brick masonry should be constructed following simple instructions for quality workmanship:
  • In dry and hot climate, masonry units should be soaked in water before the construction in order to prevent quick drying and shrinkage of cement based mortars
  • Masonry units should be assembled together in overlapped fashion (see Figure 5 and Figure 6) so that the vertical joints are staggered from course to course. To ensure adequate bonding the units should overlap by a lenght equal to 0.4 times the height of unit or 40 mm, whichever is the greater.
  • Same type of masonry units and mortar should be used for structural walls in the same storey
  • Bracing walls should be constructed in the same time as the load-bearing walls
  • The thickness of individual walls is kept constant from storey to storey
  • In cases where general purpose mortar is going to be used, the mortar joints thickness should be between 8 and 15 mm.
EC 8 specifies that, in seismic zones, the load-bearing masonry wall thickness should be min 240 mm when the masonry is confined.
To ensure stability of walls, the ratio of the effective wall height to wall thickness should be max 15.
To ensure load bearing capacity of masonry walls with openings the length of a structural wall should be at least 1/3 of the greater clear height of the openings adjacent to the wall in the case of confined masonry.
Flemish Bond
Figure 5- Flemish bond for one brick thick wall
English Bond
Figure 6- English bond for one brick thick wall
Mechanical properties for verification of masonry walls
To beginning of document
This part of the document explains the mechanical properties of masonry for verification of masonry walls. This section is included in cases where engineered building is required.
Earthquake resistance of masonry walls
In the event of an earthquake, apart from the existing gravity loads, horizontal racking loads are imposed on walls. However, the unreinforced masonry behaves as a brittle material. Hence if the stress state within the wall exceeds masonry strength, brittle failure occurs, followed by possible collapse of the wall and the building. Therefore unreinforced masonry walls are vulnerable to earthquakes, and should be confined and/or reinforced whenever possible.

Masonry walls resisting in-plane loads usually exhibit the following three modes of failure:
  • Sliding shear- a wall with poor shear strength, loaded predominantly with horizontal forces can exhibit this failure mechanism. Aspect ratio for such walls is usually 1:1 or less (1:1.5)
  • Shear- a wall loaded with significant vertical load as well as horizontal forces can fail in shear. This is the most common mode of failure. Aspect ratio for such walls is usually about 1:1. Shear failure can also occur for panels with bigger aspect ratio ie. 2:1, in cases of big vertical load.
  • Bending- this type of failure can occur if walls are with improved shear resistance. For bigger aspect ratios ie. 2:1 bending failure can occur due to small vertical loads, rather than high shear resistance. In this mode of failure the masonry panel can rock like a rigid body (in cases of low vertical loads).
Failure modes for masonry walls subject to in-plane loads are shown on Figure 7
Failure modes for masonry walls subject to in-plane loads
Figure 7- Failure modes for masonry walls subject to in-plane loads
Mechanical properties
In order to estimate the resistance of masonry walls, the following mechanical properties for the masonry needs to be determined:
  • The compressive strength- f
  • The shear strength- fv
  • The bending strength- fx
  • The stress-strain relationship, s-e
Other essential mechanical characteristics of masonry:
  • The tensile strength- ft, as an equivalent to shear strength- fv
  • The modulus of elasticity- E
  • The shear modulus- G
  • The ductility factor- m
The ductility factor is determined only for a specific structural element(specific proportions, boundary conditions etc). It cannot be determined for the masonry itself. Mechanical characteristics of masonry are determined by testing standard specimens of masonry wallets and walls according to code EN 1052.
Compressive strength
Compressive strength is determined by testing masonry specimens of at least 1.5 units length and 3 units height or by testing walls of 1.0-1.8 m length and 2.4-2.7 m height.

In cases where the masonry specimen is slender(height/thickness>20), lateral displacements at the mid height of the wall are measured. The slenderness can be taken into account using the measured value for this displacement d and the thickness of the wall t. Thus the measured compressive strength can be increased by the following factor:

t/(t-d), provided the increase is not more than 15%.

According to EN 1052-1 three identical specimens are tested and the results evaluated. In cases where the measured mean compressive strength f of masonry is different from the one of its constituents( masonry units and mortar) by 25% the value of f is modified. The characteristic compressive strength of masonry fk is determined as the smaller value of either fk=f/1.2 or fk=fmin. When verifying load bearing masonry and test data is not available, the characteristic compressive strength of plain masonry made with general purpose mortar may be calculated on the basis of normalised compressive strength of masonry units fb and compressive strength of mortar fm as follows:
fk = K*(fb0.65)*(fm0.25) [MPa],
and fm is less than 20 MPa or 2fb, whichever is the smaller. The value of constant K depends on the classification of masonry units into groups as per Table 1. Below are shown recommended values for K:
  • 0.60 for group 1 masonry units in a wall without longitudinal mortar joint,
  • 0.55 for group 2a masonry units in a wall without longitudinal mortar joint,
  • 0.50 for group 2b masonry units in a wall without longitudinal mortar joint, and for group 1 masonry units in a wall with longitudinal mortar joint,
  • 0.45 for group 2a masonry units in a wall with longitudinal mortar joint,
  • 0.40 for group 2b masonry units in a wall with longitudinal mortar joint, and for group 3 masonry units
Shear strength
Shear strength of masonry is defined as a combination of initial shear strength under zero compressive load and increase in strength due to compressive stresses perpendicular to the shear plane. Initial shear strength at zero compressive stress is denoted with fvko. This property is determined according to EN 1052-3 by testing a triplet specimen such that only shear stresses develop in the mortar to masonry unit contact planes. A minimum of five triplets are tested. The minimum acceptable value of fvko is 0.03 MPa. The characteristic shear strength of plain masonry is then calculated as follows:
fvk = fvko+0.4*sd,
where sd is the design compressive stress perpendicular to the shear plane. The value of sd should be greater than 0.065fb and a limiting value specified in EC 6 depending on masonry unit's group and mortar quality. In Table 4, are shown typical values of initial shear strength at zero compression fvko and limiting values of characteristic shear strength fvk .
Masonry
unit group
Mortar fvko [MPa] Limiting fvk
[MPa]
1
clay
M10-M20 0.3 1.7
M2.5-M9 0.2 1.5
1
other
M10-M20 0.2 1.7
M2.5-M9 0.15 1.5
2a
clay
M10-M20 0.3 1.4
M2.5-M9 0.2 1.2
2a other
2b clay
M10-M20 0.2 1.4
M2.5-M9 0.15 1.2
Table 4- Shear strength at zero compression fvko and limiting values of characteristic shear strength fvk (4)
Another approach exists for determining the shear resistance of plain masonry walls, that lead to virtually same results. According to this approach, the shear failure of masonry wall, ie. diagonal cracking of the wall, is caused by the principal tensile stresses.
The shear strength can be determined by reducing the masonry wall to a structural element from elastic, homogeneous and isotropic material, experiencing plane stress state. For this purpose are evaluated the principal compressive and tensile stresses, respectively that develop in the middle section of the wall. Thus the value of the principal tensile stresses, measured when the wall panel is loaded in shear at failure, defines the tensile strength, ft. The equations for principal compressive and the principal tensile stresses in plain masonry wall panel under vertical load- N, and lateral load- H, are :
sc = SQRT((so/2)2+(b*t)2)+so/2 ,
st = SQRT((so/2)2+(b*t)2)-so/2 ,
And the plane of the principal stresses is defined as follows:
fc = ft = 0.5*ARCTAN(2*t/so),
where the meaning of symbols in the above equations are as follows:
so = N/Aw - average compressive stress due to vertical load N,
t = H/Aw - average shear stress due to lateral load H,
Aw - the horizontal cross section area of the wall,
b - the shear stress distribution factor, depending on the geometry of the wall and N/Hmax ratio. For a wall with geometrical aspect ratio height/length=1.5, b=1.5 .
Hmax - the maximum resistance of masonry wall
The principal tensile stress that develop in the wall at the moment of maximum resistance- Hmax is called the tensile strength of masonry:
ft = st = SQRT((so/2)2+(b*tHmax)2)-so/2 ,
In the above equation ft is the tensile strength of masonry and
tHmax- the average shear stress in the wall at the attained maximum resistance Hmax
The lateral resistance Hs,w of a plain masonry wall panel, loaded in shear is evaluated by :
Hs,w = Aw*(ft/b)*SQRT((so/ft)+1)
When the resistance envelope is bilinear relationship, the above equation is multiplied by a factor of 0.9. If the design value of the shear resistance Hsd,w should be correlated with the design seismic action, in the above equation take part the characteristic value of tensile strength and a material partial safety factor :
Hsd,w = Aw*(ftk/cM*b)*SQRT((sdcM/ftk)+1)
There is currently no standard testing procedure for evaluating the shear strength fv or tensile strength ft.
One possibility is to use monotonic diagonal compression test. Another test is subjecting the wall panel to monotonic or cyclic racking load. The effect of compressive stresses in the masonry is taken into account in these tests. Table 5 shows values of characteristic tensile strength of masonry -ftk correlated with values for the initial shear strength at zero compressive stress- fvko
Unit
[MPa]
Group Mortar
[MPa]
Strength [MPa]
ftk fvko
10 1 - clay 0.5 0.04 0.10
15 1 - clay 2.5 0.18 0.20
7.5 2a - clay 2 0.30 0.10
15 2a - clay 2.5 0.12 0.20
15 2a - clay 5 0.18 0.20
7.5 2a - other 5 0.27 0.15
7.5 2a - other 5 0.27 0.15
7.5 2b - clay 3 0.10 0.20
Table 5- Correlation between experimental characteristic tensile strength ftk and initial shear strength fvk0 of masonry (14)
By analysing test results it has been established that the ratio between the tensile and compressive strength of any type of masonry varies in the following margins:
0.03fk <= ftk <= 0.09fk
Bending strength
In cases where the masonry needs to be verified for out-of-plane loads the bending strength is the governing factor. The bending strength parallel to bed joints (see Figure 9) is denoteed with fx1 and the bending strength perpendicular to bed joints (see Figure 8) is denoted with fx2. According to EC 6 the value of fx1 should be taken as zero when evaluating seismic resistance.
Vertical orientation of failure plane and corresponding bending strength normal to bed joints
Figure 8- Vertical orientation of failure plane and corresponding bending strength normal to bed joints
Horizontal orientation of failure plane and corresponding bending strength parallel to bed joints
Figure 9- Horizontal orientation of failure plane and corresponding bending strength parallel to bed joints
Elastic properties
The modulus of elasticity E of masonry can be determined after compression tests. The elastic modulus is defined as a secant modulus at service load condition. This load level corresponds to 1/3 of the maximum vertical load.
When determined by testing E modulus value is not available the following equation may be used :
E=1000fk
However in the calculated value of E modulus may not be correct. Reliable E values are the one in the margin:
200fk <= E <= 2000fk
Theoretically and as specified in EC 6 the G modulus is evaluated as being 40% of the E modulus. In reality the values of shear modulus G are much lower. Reliable G values are the one in the margin:
1000ftk <= G <= 2700ftk
The discrepancy between experimental and predicted values for the mechanical properties of masonry can be explained with the composite nature of the material. There are wide variety of not only masonry units but also mortars and various composition of the masonry wall itself. Therefore the testing of masonry is essential step in seismic resistance verification of masonry houses.
Planning and layout
To beginning of document
Surveys of earthquake damaged residential masonry wall houses and analysis of the causes of damage indicate that well tied buildings with well defined, continuous load path to the foundations perform much better in earthquakes than building lacking such features. Well defined, continuous load path can be achieved with regular structural layout and uniformity both in plan and elevation. The degree of symmetry is also found to have a significant influence on earthquake resistance. Damage can be five to ten times worse in irregular buildings compared to regular ones.

Thus satisfactory seismic behaviour can be guaranteed by following the requirements for regular and uniform layout both in plan and elevation, interconnectivity between structural members and strength of materials.

To summarise an earthquake resistant structural form for masonry wall structure is the one which is:
  • Regular both in plan and elevation i.e. uniform and symmetrical
  • Redundant - capable of providing adequate resistance even after a failure of a structural member
  • With rigid floors interconnected with walls that ensure diaphragm action
  • Stable foundation should be provided able to transmit the maximum seismic loads from the superstructure to the foundation soil
Masonry buildings with horizontal irreguliarities and lack of symmetry may have considerable eccentricity between the mass centre and stiffness centre giving rise to damaging coupled lateral/torsional response. Horizontal irregularities in the form of extensions, projections etc. may cause stress concentration and local failures since these extensions are prone to vibrate separetely from the rest of the structure.
On the other hand vertical irregularity in masonry building may cause stress concentration at a horizontal plane that can lead to total collapse. In order to achieve satisfactory redundancy at least to lines of load bearing walls are required in each principal direction of the building. Lack of rigid floors will prevent proportionate load transfer onto walls at each floor level as well as will not provide out of plane restraint. Not supported masonry walls at floor level tends to separate at corners and/or fail out of their plane, causing collapse of floor or roof.
According to EC 8 the following general criteria for structural regularity in plan and elevation should be considered:
  • The building structure is approximately symmetrical along each principal axis in plan, for both stiffness and mass distribution. A sufficient number of load bearing walls with approximately the same stiffness, should be provided in both principal direction of the building -see Figure 10
BuildConfigurationPlan
Figure 10- Structural walls distribution in plan
BuildConfigurationRegular
Figure 11- Examples of regular configuration of masonry houses in plan
BuildConfigurationMadeRegular
Figure 12- Irregular configurations in plan should be separated in regular portions
Plan dimensions and height or number of storeys
Limitations concerning the height of masonry wall houses have been set in most existing seismic codes. Currently EC 8 limits the construction of confined brick masonry houses located in seismic zones with high seismic risk ie. ag => 0.3g to four storey houses. However confined brick masonry wall buildings which conform with the specifications for structural configuration and quality of materials, the dimensions of the building are not limited by the code. In this case the dimensions of the house are determined by design calculations based on the load bearing capacity of the masonry. The building should be verified according to ultimate limit states.

On the other hand based on the experience from past earthquake as well as the existing technologies for masonry housing construction it is recommended that the height and number of storeys conform with Table 8. The reinforced grouted cavity wall type of engineered structural masonry is exempted from these limitations.
Design ground acceleration ag < 0.2 [g] 0.2 - 0.3 [g] >= 0.3 [g]
Unreinforced masonry H [m] 12 9 6
n 4 3 2
Confined Masonry H [m] 18 15 12
n 6 5 4
Reinforced masonry H [m] 24 21 18
n 8 7 6
Table 8- Recommended maximum building height H and number of storeys n (14)
Distance between masonry bearing walls and wall openings
In EC 8 there is no requirement for maximum distance between walls. However based on experience for different type of masonry houses it is recommended that the distance between walls conform to Table 9 :
Design ground acceleration ag < 0.2 [g] 0.2 - 0.3 [g] >= 0.3 [g]
Unreinforced masonry [m] 10 8 6
Confined Masonry [m] 15 12 8
Reinforced masonry [m] 15 12 8
Table 9- Recommended maximum distance between structural walls (6)
Another essential factor is the structural wall continuity. This means that the size and configuration of openings in walls should be carefully planned.
The following recommendations regarding the configuration and size of openings should be observed:
  • Openings should be vertically aligned from storey to strorey
  • The top ends of openings in the storey should be horizontally aligned
  • Openings should not stop continuous RC bond beams (at lintel and/or roof level)
  • Openings should be located symmetrically in the plan of the building so that not to get in the way of the uniform distribution of strength and stiffness in two orthogonal directions.
Simple houses
To beginning of document
According to EC 8 certain class of masonry housing can be exempt from seismic resistance verification provided that the quality of materials and construction rules specified in the code are met. Such houses are named "simple buildings". According to EC 8 simple buildings are regular buildings with an approximately rectangular plan. The ratio between the long to shorter side of the house is no more to four and the projections or recesses from the rectangular shape are not greater than 15% of the length of the side parallel to the direction of projection. Such houses have the following limitations regarding number of storeys above ground (Table 10):
Design ground
acceleration ag
< 0.2 [g] 0.2 - 0.3 [g] >= 0.3 [g]
Unreinforced masonry 3 2 1
Confined Masonry 4 3 2
Reinforced masonry 5 4 3
Table 10- Number of storeys above ground, allowed for simple buildings (6)
For a masonry house to comply with a simple building a number of specifications are given for the masonry walls. The structural walls should be symetrically located in plan in two orthogonal directions. A minimum of two structural walls per orthogonal direction. The length of each wall should be greater than 30% of the length of the building in the wall plane and the distance between these walls should be maximum 75% of the size of the building in the other direction. The minimum cross sectional area of the structural walls is also specified in EC 8. At every floor, the area of the structural walls in two orthogonal directions is provided as a percentage of the total floor area above the level considered. Table 11 below gives the minimum horizontal structural wall cross-section :
Design ground
acceleration ag
< 0.2 [g] 0.2 - 0.3 [g] >= 0.3 [g]
Unreinforced masonry 3 5 6
Confined Masonry 2 4 5
Reinforced masonry 2 4 5
Table 11- Minimum horizontal structural wall cross-section, given as % of the total floor area above the level considered (6)
To enforce reguliarity, the difference in structural walls cross-sectional area in two orthogonal directions from storey to storey should be maximum 20%. The difference in the mass of structural walls in two orthogonal directions from storey to storey should be as well maximum 20%. For such buildings it is also required that 75% of the vertical load is carried from the structural walls.
Details for seismic resistance
To beginning of document
Concept
The performance of building subject to an earthquake motions is governed by the inter-connectivity of structural components as well as the individual component's strength, stiffness and ductility. Thus the details to provide seismic resistance can be classified in two categories:
Details for complete load path
  • Provide wall to wall connection ie. tying of walls
  • Provide means for walls to foundations connection
  • Provide connection of bond beams to roof
  • Provide connection of walls to bond beams
  • Provide stiff in their plane floors/roofs
Details to improve structural components strength and ductility
  • Improve the compressive strength of structural components
  • Improve the bending strength of structural components
  • Improve the shear strength of structural components
  • Improve the ductility, m of the structural components
 
Bond beams
In the case of confined masonry construction bond beams are constructed as part of the vertical and horizontal masonry confining elements. Bond-beams should be constructed in-situ from reinforced concrete and cast simultaneously with the floor slab. Bond-beams should be cast on top of all structural walls at every floor level. The minimum bond beam's cross section is recommended to be 150x250. The bigger dimension being the thickness of the wall. Typical examples of monolithic cast in-situ RC bond beams with RC slabs are shown below on Figure 13.
Details of cast in-situ RC slabs with bond beams
Figure 13- Details of cast in-situ RC slabs with bond beams
Maximum vertical distance between bond-beams is 4 m. Bond-beams are constructed because:
  • Forms confined masonry shear walls in combination with tie-columns
  • Improves the in-plane stiffness of floors to provide diaphragm action
  • Transfers the horizontal load from the diaphragm to the structural walls
  • Connects the structural walls together and provides out-of-plane support
  • Connects the RC tie-columns
EC8 specifies the following minimum requirements:
  • Concrete of class 15 should be used
  • Cross section size should be not less than 150x150 mm
  • Four mild steel rebars with total area 240 mm2
  • To ensure integrity of the bond beam the longitudinal rebars at corners and wall intersections should be spliced a length of 60f
  • Transverse reinforcement-stirrups rebars f6 @ 200 mm intervals
Figure 14 illustrates bond beam reinforcement at corners
Bond beam reinforcement at a corner
Figure 14- Detail of RC bond beam showing splicing of rebars at wall corners
According to EC 8 the resistance of the RC bond-beam should not be taken into consideration in the design calculations. Consequantly there is no mandatory design through calculation for the bond-beams. As was discussed in the confined masonry section the design parameters are determined on empirical basis. In Table 12 the members reinforcement can be determined based on the seismicity of the location the number of stroreys and position.
Number of
storeys
Position
(storey)
Low:
< 0.2 [g]
Moderate:
0.2 - 0.3 [g]
High:
>= 0.3 [g]
2 1-2 4 bars, f8 mm 4 bars, f10 mm 4 bars, f12 mm
4 1-2 4 bars, f10 mm 4 bars, f12 mm 4 bars, f14 mm
4 2-4 4 bars, f8 mm 4 bars, f10 mm 4 bars, f12 mm
6 1-2 4 bars, f12 mm 4 bars, f14 mm 4 bars, f16 mm
6 3-4 4 bars, f10 mm 4 bars, f12 mm 4 bars, f14 mm
6 5-6 4 bars, f8 mm 4 bars, f10 mm 4 bars, f12 mm
Table 12 Recommended reinforcement of horizontal RC bond-beams (9)
Tie-columns
Although the tie-columns and bond beams do not provide frame system adequate splicing and anchoring of rebars is required at all joints. Sixty rebar diameters splices are required according to EC 8.

The cross-sectional area of rebars for tie-columns can be selected in dependence of seismicity of the location and number of storeys in the house. Such data is presented Table 5. On Figure 15 below is illustrated the splicing of rebars between bond beam and tie-column.
Construction of tie-column for confined brick masonry house
Figure 15- Construction of tie-column for confined brick masonry house
Floors and roofs
In EC 8 it is specified that the floor and roof structure can be constructed in timber or reinforced concrete, provided a diaphragm action can be achieved. When building confined masonry houses RC floor slabs cast in-situ are preferred.

Apart from developing diaphragm action and transfer of the seismic forces onto the walls the floors and roof should support the walls out of their plane, ie. all structural walls should be restrained at floor/roof level. In the case of RC slab the connection is provided naturally by constructing RC bond beam onto the structural walls. In the case of a timber joist floor the floor joists should be tied to the walls by means of steel ties. The anchoring of the timber floor joists to masonry walls may be more difficult to achieve.

Therefore the construction of monolithic RC slabs is recommended. Floor systems made of prefabricated RC elements and cast in situ topping are not recommended.
Common roof systems constructed in timber for low-rise masonry housing are the joist-rafter roof and the truss roof. The joist-rafter roof system tends to spread and overturn masonry walls. Therefore a collar beam attached to rafters is required. To ensure diaphragm action bracing and blocking should be constructed both in the plane of the joists and in the plane of the rafters in two othogonal directions. Only the perimeter joists and rafters may be included in bracing and blocking. Vertical cross bracing in the longitudinal ridge plane( perpendiculiar to the joists) is also required. To achieve a satisfactory restraint on the walls the ceiling joists should be anchored to the provided RC roof bond beam by means of steel strap placed in position in the bond-beam's formwork before casting of the bond-beam. See Figure 16:
Timber roof anchorage to bond beam
Figure 16- Timber roof anchorage to bond beam
RC roofs can be also constructed. They can be both flat RC slabs or sloped systems cast together with the roof bond beam. These roofs can provide diaphragm action and wall restraint however their mass is much higher. In order to reduce seismic loads light roofs are favoured. Light roof cover( tiles) should be used preferably.
Lintels and cantilever elements
Lintels are load-bearing elements which support the weight of the wall and floor above opening. Lintels can be made from in-situ reinforced concrete, timber and reinforced masonry. In seismic zones cast in-situ RC lintels are recommended. If the distance between the top of the opening to the top of the floor above is less than 600 mm the lintel can be cast simultaneously with the bond beam and floor slab as shown on Figure 17. In cases where the distance is bigger the lintels can be cast separately (Figure 17) and care should be taken to bond the RC lintels to the masonry of the adjoining wall through horizontal rebars.
Requirements for lintels in seismic zones
Figure 17- Requirements for lintels in seismic zones (9)
Where the area of the opening is more than 2.5 m2, tie-columns are required on both sides of opening. The reinforcement of lintels should be anchored into the rc tie-columns. It is also recommended that lintels should be embedded in the walls a minimum of 250 mm. The lintel width should be equal to the wall thickness and should not be less than 150 mm.
Cantilever structural elements in masonry houses like balconies and various forms of overhangs are vulnerable in an event of an earthquake. These portions of the structure are iinherently flexible in vertical direction( out-of-plane) and are prone to vibrate separately from the rest of the structure during an earthquake. In order to reduce vertical motion of balconies, overhangs and other cantilever elements the following limitations are set:
  • 1.20 m for cantilever slabs cast continuously with the floor slabs, and
  • 0.50 m for cantilever slabs anchored into the bond-beams without the continuity with the floor slab
Design of bigger cantilevers is possible however a rigorous analysis is required accounting for the vertical component of the seismic motion. According to EC 8 when verifying a portion of the structure on the vertical component of seismic motion a partial model is adequate including the cantilever element and taking into account the stiffness of the adjacent elements to ensure realistic boundary conditions. According to EC 8 the response spectrum as defined in previous section is applicable but with the following corrections:
  • For periods T < 0.15s the ordinates of the spectrum are multiplied by 0.7
  • For periods 0.15s < T < 0.5s a linearly interpolated value between 0.7 and 0.5
  • For periods T > 0.5s the ordinates of the spectrum are multiplied by 0.5
Non-load bearing elements
Failures of non-load bearing elements, such as partition walls, chimneys, masonry veneer, architectural details, etc, can cause casualties and structural damage. In order to prevent failure and fall-downs of masonry non-structural elements their out-of-plane stability to seimic loads should be verified by calculation according to EC 8.

Partition walls are made of most types of masonry units including solid ones. The usual partition walls thickness is about 100 mm and they can be plain or reinforced. The reinforcing can be by means of rebars f4 to f6 placed in the masonry bed joints every 500 mm. The partition walls are usually confined in vertical direction by the floors through cement based mortar joints. In horizontal direction the partitions are confined from RC tie-columns or structural walls through steel anchors or just bond.

When constructing timber ridged roof, the triangular area formed by the sloping ends of the roof can be filled with masonry forming a gable end wall. Out-of-plane failures of gable end walls are common during strong earthquakes and therefore require special consideration. It is recommended that masonry gable end walls and attics higher than 0.5 m are anchored to the uppermost floor bond-beams. The gable end walls should be confined by a bond beam running along the roof line. In cases where the height of the gable end wall is more than 4 m, intermidiate bond-beams should be added not more than 2m apart, see Figure 18. As discussed in the confined masonry section the maximum distance between vertical confining elements is 4m.
Provision of bond beams and tie-columns to secure gable end walls and attics
Figure 18- Provision of bond beams and tie-columns to secure gable end walls and attics
For architectural purposes external solid walls can be constructed as faced or veneered walls. The faced wall is built with different masonry units bonded together to achieve common action under loading. Veneered walls has facing attached, but not bonded to the backing leaf. The load applied to veneered wall is assumed to be carried by the backing leaf only which is designed on the basis of no structural contribution from the veneer. The veneer can be anchored by means of steel ties to the backing masonry wall. No specific requirements can be found in EC 8 however its stability can be verified using the formulaes applied to out-of-plane stability of partition walls.

Heavy masonry chimneys and ventilation stacks represent a considerable hazard in the event of an earthquake. If the chimney is not built of reinforced masonry an effective solution might be to deconstruct it and complete it in reinforced masonry or replace it altogether with a lighter metal chimney. In the case of reinforced masonry chimney the rebars should be anchored into the top floor. Architectural details, like cornices, vertical or horizontal cantiliver projections, etc., should be reinforced and anchored into the main RC strucure. The out-of-plane behaviour should be verified by calculation according to the guidance provided for partition walls.
Seismic resistance verification of masonry buildings
To beginning of document
This portion of the confined brick masonry section is included in cases where engineered building is required. No specific procedures and/or algorithms for seismic resistance analysis and verification are outlined in EC 8. The following calculation procedures for seismic resistance verification based on linear analysis are usually required:
  • The weight, W=mass*9.81 at each floor level is calculated based on the characteristic value of permanent action( ie.self-weight of the structure) and portion of the characteristic value of variable load

  • The stiffness of individual structural walls in the storey under consideration is calculated
    Analysing a structural wall with rectangular cross section as an element being fixed at the floors the following formulae for the bending stiffness is obtained:

    Ke = G*Aw/1.2*h(1+a'*(G/E)*(h/l)2) [Force/displacement],
    where the meaning of symbols is as follows:
    Ke = effective stiffness defined as being the ratio between the resistance and displacement of the wall at crack limit,
    h = the height of the wall,
    l = the width of the wall,
    G = the shear modulus of masonry infills,
    E = modulus of elasticity,
    Aw = the area of the cross section of the wall,
    a' = coefficient based on the location of the inflection point in the deformed shape of the wall. a'=0.83 in the case of fixed-ended wall and a'=3.33 in the case of a cantilever wall.
Deformed shape of a fixed-ended wall subjected to lateral loading
Figure 19- Deformed shape of a fixed-ended wall subjected to lateral loading
Vertical distribution of base shear
Figure 20- Vertical distribution of base shear
To beginning of document
City University